If you’ve been shooting digital for a while, you’ve probably been through the same cycle most of us have:
You love the look of film not just the colors, but the way it renders light. The tonal separation that keeps greens and yellows distinct instead of letting them bleed together. The gentle highlight roll-off that never feels clipped. Skin tones that actually look like skin, not the orange masks that so many edits produce.
So naturally, you tried to get there digitally. You bought preset packs, watched tutorials, and spent hours tweaking HSL sliders and tone curves, trying to reverse-engineer what film does on its own. Sometimes it even looked close, but it was never consistent. What kinda looked like film on one image quickly fell apart on the next. On Reddit, photographers have jokingly called this "preset roulette." Every new lighting situation seemed to break the edit, and the more small tweaks you made, the further you drifted from anything that felt organic.
Meanwhile, the photographers whose work you admire seem to have figured something out. Their edits look effortless and cohesive, like there's a foundation underneath that just works across scenes, cameras, and lighting conditions. At some point, you started wondering if maybe you're missing something fundamental.